Chronic pain claims are a distinct and often difficult area of personal injury law. These conditions - complex regional pain syndrome (CRPS), fibromyalgia, chronic pain syndrome, chronic post-surgical pain - are diagnosed on clinical criteria rather than on objective imaging, and their valuation turns heavily on expert pain-medicine evidence. They typically develop after another injury (a fracture that doesn't settle; a surgical procedure; a crush injury; a whiplash) and sit on top of the original injury's valuation. The Judicial College Guidelines 17th edition (April 2024) has severe-through-moderate brackets for CRPS and for 'chronic pain syndromes and similar'.
Casibus works with SRA-regulated personal injury specialists on a no win, no fee basis. Every case depends on its evidence.
JCG 17th edition chronic pain brackets
Complex regional pain syndrome (CRPS) - severe
CRPS with very significant ongoing effects including impact on ability to work and daily function, need for long-term pain medication, psychological sequelae. JCG 17th edition top-of-bracket reaches mid-five to low-six figures.
CRPS - moderate
Ongoing significant symptoms but less severe or with better prognosis than the severe bracket. Typically low to mid-five figures.
Fibromyalgia / chronic pain syndrome - moderate to severe
The JCG 'other pain disorders' bracket covers fibromyalgia, somatoform pain disorder, chronic pain syndrome, chronic post-surgical pain. Valuation runs from low-five figures at the bottom of the bracket to mid-five figures at the top for severe disabling cases where the condition has substantial functional impact and poor prognosis.
Short-term chronic pain
Post-traumatic pain lasting beyond expected recovery but which resolves over time. The lower end of the bracket.
Complex regional pain syndrome - what it is and how it's proved
CRPS is a neuropathic / neuropsychological pain disorder in a limb following injury (often relatively minor), characterised by pain out of proportion to the inciting injury, sensory changes (allodynia, hyperalgesia), vasomotor signs (temperature / colour asymmetry), sudomotor signs (sweating asymmetry, oedema), and motor / trophic changes. Diagnosis uses the 'Budapest criteria' (signs and symptoms across 4 domains). Type I (formerly RSD) follows without identified nerve injury; Type II (formerly causalgia) follows identified nerve injury.
Proving CRPS in litigation requires: (i) an expert pain-medicine consultant (ideally Faculty of Pain Medicine accredited); (ii) Budapest-criteria-compliant clinical findings; (iii) ruling out alternative explanations; (iv) functional capacity evaluation; (v) often psychological / psychiatric assessment given the common overlap with anxiety, depression, and post-traumatic adjustment. The defendant's expert will probe the diagnosis vigorously; our instructed experts are selected accordingly.
Fibromyalgia and chronic pain syndrome in litigation
Fibromyalgia is a chronic widespread pain disorder with fatigue, sleep disturbance and cognitive features; it's diagnosed clinically using the ACR criteria (tender points historically, now more symptom-based). Chronic pain syndrome is a broader category covering pain persisting beyond expected recovery time, typically with psychological / behavioural sequelae.
The litigation challenge is causation. A claimant with pre-existing fibromyalgia or a chronic-pain tendency may develop disabling symptoms after an accident; the question is whether the accident caused, accelerated or exacerbated the condition. 'Eggshell skull' principles apply - you take the claimant as you find them - so an accident that materially worsens a pre-existing chronic-pain tendency is actionable. Expert rheumatology / pain-medicine evidence plus detailed pre-accident GP records settle the causation question. NICE NG193 (chronic primary pain) informs the clinical framework.
Common routes to a chronic pain claim
- Orthopaedic injury that doesn't settle - a wrist fracture, ankle fracture, or shoulder surgery that develops CRPS afterwards.
Special damages in chronic pain claims
- Pain-medicine specialist input - nerve blocks, radiofrequency ablation, spinal cord stimulators (for severe CRPS).
